Observations along the way

Notes

Not every thought needs a thousand words. Some need room to breathe.

Public authority is held in trust, not owned by the people temporarily exercising it. No private contract, political contribution, professional relationship, administrative procedure or statutory loophole should convert that trust into an instrument of private rule.

The Hypocrisy of the Squeaky Wheel

A man with a Southern drawl recently pointed out the peculiar sight of someone wearing $150 sneakers, speaking into a $1,000 phone, and declaring themselves oppressed.

It’s a good line. You can almost hear a porch chair creak beneath it. And there are people who ought to hear it, especially those who mistake the absence of applause for persecution and a mildly unpleasant interaction for a historic injustice.

But a good line can become a lazy argument if we let it do all the thinking.

The phone may be financed. The shoes may have been a gift. Neither item tells us what happened at work, what the landlord did, or what it costs that person to walk through a world we experience differently. You cannot audit a stranger’s life by glancing at their feet.

You can, however, ask what they mean by oppression. That word ought to carry more weight than a customer-service complaint.

Some people have grown remarkably skilled at turning comfort into grievance. They have a platform, an audience, a wardrobe selected for the occasion, and the conviction that every closed door is a personal attack. If someone disagrees with them, they’ve been silenced. If a rule applies to them, they’ve been targeted. If they don’t get the outcome they wanted, the entire system must be rigged.

Sometimes a system is rigged. That is precisely why we should resent the people who use its language to describe a bruised ego. They consume the attention needed by someone whose wages were stolen, whose care was denied, or whose complaint disappeared into an office that knows nobody will come looking for it.

The squeaky wheel is supposed to alert us to a problem. These days, some wheels come fitted with a microphone, a merchandise table, and a subscription link. They have learned that outrage draws a crowd. Why stop squeaking long enough to fix anything when the noise is paying the bills?

And before the man on the porch gets too comfortable, he has some explaining to do as well.

It is wonderfully convenient to judge another person’s hardship by the nicest thing they own. It saves us the trouble of asking what happened. Better still, it lets us feel wise while knowing almost nothing. A phone becomes a verdict. A pair of sneakers becomes a complete economic history. Poverty, apparently, is only credible if you arrive barefoot and communicate by smoke signal.

That, too, is the hypocrisy of the squeaky wheel: demanding that other people justify their complaints while treating our own irritation as self-evidently righteous.

We need a better test than the price of somebody’s shoes or the volume of their voice. What happened? Who had power? What harm was done? Can it be shown? What would repair it? And is the person making the noise willing to share the wheel when someone else has a stronger claim?

A complaint can be legitimate even when its owner has nice things. It can also be ridiculous when its owner has very little. Hardship is not a costume, and outrage is not proof.

Listen when the wheel squeaks. Then look underneath the cart. Sometimes there’s a broken axle. Sometimes there’s a stone in the road. And sometimes somebody installed a foghorn because it was easier than learning to steer.

The moment someone becomes convinced that their political identity establishes their virtue, they acquire a remarkable capacity to excuse their own misconduct.

History isn’t an inheritance we merely admire. It’s an unfinished responsibility we inherit.

You want to establish a public record of someone who gives a damn, thinks independently, respects evidence, and isn’t afraid to get angry when anger is warranted?

Good.

That’s entirely compatible with intellectual integrity.

You can be furious and correct.

You can be irreverent and thoughtful.

You can be compassionate and absolutely fucking merciless toward a dishonest argument.

And you can change your mind without surrendering your convictions.

The most consequential rewriting of history may not be changing what people believe happened. It may be changing what people believe was ever possible.

I believe in entrepreneurship. I believe in innovation, private enterprise, competition, and rewarding people who take risks and build something worthwhile.

What I don’t believe in is treating capitalism like a fucking religion whose wealthiest practitioners are automatically its high priests.

And I certainly don’t believe that questioning the behavior of billionaires makes someone jealous, lazy, hateful, or evil.

That’s not an argument. That’s intellectual surrender dressed up as economic philosophy.

Let’s get something straight.

Capitalism is an economic system. It is not a moral authority.

Its legitimacy comes from how well it serves human beings, not how efficiently it concentrates wealth and power in the hands of a few.

Peter Barnes explored this beautifully in his 2006 book Capitalism 3.0: A Guide to Reclaiming the Commons.

His argument, in essence, is that capitalism needs an upgrade—one that recognizes the natural resources, public institutions, shared knowledge, and inherited wealth of civilization upon which private enterprise depends.

Because nobody builds a multibillion-dollar empire entirely by themselves.

Not Elon Musk. Not Jeff Bezos. Not Mark Zuckerberg. Nobody.

They build upon generations of publicly supported research, infrastructure, education, technological development, and the work of enormous numbers of other human beings.

Their employees don’t merely help them become wealthy.

Their employees help create the wealth.

And the public helps create the conditions that make that wealth possible.

Now, here’s a little American economic history that seems to have escaped the billionaire-worshipping congregation.

During much of the 1950s and early 1960s, the highest federal marginal income-tax rate was 91%.

Ninety-one fucking percent.

That didn’t mean wealthy people surrendered 91% of everything they earned. It applied to income above the highest tax threshold, and effective rates were considerably lower.

But here’s what matters.

Some of the highest marginal income-tax rates in American history existed alongside one of the most extraordinary periods of sustained economic expansion the country had ever experienced.

Businesses expanded. Productivity increased. The middle class grew. Workers purchased homes, raised families, and participated in an extraordinary period of economic development.

That prosperity was neither universal nor the product of any single economic policy. Industrial development, organized labor, public investment, technological progress, international conditions, and countless other forces contributed to it.

But those extraordinarily high marginal rates were part of the economic landscape.

And wealthy Americans continued accumulating wealth.

So perhaps we can dispense with the fairy tale that taxing the wealthiest Americans at substantially higher rates necessarily brings economic civilization crashing down around our ears.

Now let’s examine something considerably more interesting.

Who actually receives the wealth that an enterprise creates?

Because not all employees occupy the same economic universe.

At the upper levels of successful technology companies, highly specialized engineers, executives, and other strategically important employees can command extraordinary compensation packages, including salaries, bonuses, and substantial equity.

Companies compete fiercely for these people because their knowledge, relationships, and continued participation may be enormously valuable.

Move down the organizational hierarchy, however, and the picture can change dramatically.

Warehouse workers. Delivery drivers. Maintenance personnel. Customer-service representatives. Food-service workers. Contractors. The people who keep the physical and operational machinery functioning.

Their bargaining power, access to equity, job security, and ability to negotiate compensation can be vastly different.

Yet their labor remains indispensable.

A company cannot deliver products without the people who move them. It cannot operate facilities without the people who maintain them. It cannot serve customers without the people who do the serving.

Indispensable work does not always command indispensable wages.

And that is one of the central moral contradictions of modern capitalism.

According to the Economic Policy Institute, between 1979 and 2025, productivity increased at an annualized rate of 1.4%, while typical hourly pay increased just 0.6%.

Workers became substantially more productive, but typical compensation did not keep pace.

The benefits of economic growth have not been distributed evenly.

And those disparities become particularly troubling when the people with the least economic leverage are also those struggling to afford housing, food, transportation, healthcare, and the ordinary necessities of a dignified existence.

Let’s be clear about something.

A wage is not morally adequate simply because an employer can find someone desperate enough to accept it.

The market may establish a price for someone’s labor.

It does not establish the worth of the human being performing it.

And when a company generates extraordinary wealth while people performing essential work within its operations cannot afford a decent standard of living, that is a legitimate subject of moral and economic scrutiny.

It is not envy.

It is not hatred.

And it certainly isn’t an attack on entrepreneurship.

Now consider our modern technology billionaires.

Some are extraordinarily talented entrepreneurs and innovators. Their accomplishments deserve to be examined on their merits.

But technological brilliance, business success, and enormous personal wealth do not automatically confer wisdom, maturity, ethical judgment, or a mandate to redesign human civilization.

Yet we’ve created an economic environment in which a relatively small number of extraordinarily wealthy individuals can exercise enormous influence over communication, employment, information, infrastructure, and public policy.

Their personal visions can become society-wide experiments, often without anything resembling democratic consent.

And we’re supposed to applaud because they’re rich?

Bullshit.

A billion dollars is not a philosophy degree.

A hundred billion dollars is not a moral credential.

And being able to build a rocket doesn’t mean you understand what makes a civilization worth inhabiting.

The problem isn’t wealth itself.

The problem is wealth becoming so concentrated that private ambition can overwhelm public accountability.

Meanwhile, we’re told that people receiving public assistance are parasites.

Interesting.

Public investment helps educate the workforce, build infrastructure, fund research, protect property, and establish the legal systems upon which private wealth depends.

Businesses may also receive subsidies, tax incentives, and other forms of public support.

But when assistance helps a family buy groceries, suddenly we’re supposed to believe civilization is collapsing under the weight of freeloaders.

What a remarkably convenient moral distinction.

And here’s the part that seems to disappear from these conversations entirely.

Human beings are not merely economic units.

We are not born to spend our lives demonstrating that we deserve to exist by generating sufficient profit for somebody else.

We are people.

We have families, relationships, aspirations, vulnerabilities, communities, and lives that extend beyond the hours we sell to an employer.

An economy that generates extraordinary wealth while leaving substantial numbers of the people who sustain it struggling to live with dignity has a problem that cannot be explained away by pointing to its balance sheets.

Because the purpose of civilization is not to maximize the net worth of its wealthiest participants.

It is to create conditions in which human beings can flourish.

I don’t want to destroy capitalism.

I want an economic system mature enough to recognize that human prosperity is the purpose of economic activity—not an inconvenient expense to be minimized in pursuit of private fortunes.

Markets are tools.

Corporations are institutions.

Money is a medium of exchange and a measure of certain kinds of value.

None of them is sacred.

Human dignity, opportunity, community, environmental stewardship, and the ability of future generations to flourish deserve a place at the center of our economic decisions.

If our version of capitalism cannot reliably serve those purposes, then it needs to evolve.

Not because capitalism is inherently evil.

Because no economic system deserves permanent immunity from improvement.

And if the only defense someone can offer for the existing arrangement is that its critics are jealous, lazy, or hateful, perhaps it’s time to stop worshipping the machinery long enough to examine what the fucking machinery is actually producing.

People before profit.

Not because profit is bad.

Because profit is supposed to serve people.

Not the other way around.

Religious social-media meme urging readers to type Amen to disappoint Satan, with highlighted Bible references.

GOD, SATAN, AND THE DEPARTMENT OF DIVINE FACEBOOK ENGAGEMENT

Or: How the Creator of the Universe Apparently Became a Social Media Influencer

Well, I’ll be damned.

Apparently, God Almighty—the eternal, omnipotent, omniscient creator of approximately two trillion galaxies, give or take a cosmic rounding error—has taken a personal interest in my Facebook feed.

According to this inspirational little theological fortune cookie, God specifically arranged for me to encounter it TODAY, NOT TOMORROW.

Extraordinary.

One might reasonably wonder why the architect of spacetime, who allegedly knows every hair on every head, would need to communicate through a recycled Facebook graphic rather than simply addressing the matter directly.

Perhaps the heavenly communications department has suffered budget cuts.

Perhaps Gabriel has retired.

Perhaps the Holy Spirit has been outsourced to Meta.

Whatever the explanation, here we are.

And apparently, Satan is involved.

Naturally.

Because no inspirational religious chain letter is complete without a supernatural villain whose eternal plans can be thwarted by typing AMEN beneath a photograph of highlighted Bible verses.

But before we get to His Infernal Majesty and his apparently catastrophic engagement statistics, let’s examine what the Bible actually says.

GOD IS EVERYWHERE. EXCEPT, APPARENTLY, WHERE THE MEME SAYS HE ISN’T.

Genesis begins with God creating the heavens and the earth.

Psalm 139 asks where anyone could flee from God’s presence. The answer, rather inconveniently for anyone claiming exclusive divine companionship, is nowhere.

Acts 17:28 declares that in God we live, move, and have our being.

Colossians 1:17 says that all things hold together in Christ.

Now, these passages don’t necessarily teach that God is every object in existence. Classical Christian theology distinguishes the Creator from creation.

But they certainly present God as universally present and sustaining existence.

Which raises a fascinating question:

If God is everywhere, how exactly does one arrange to be somewhere God isn’t?

Does God maintain restricted-access areas?

Are there neighborhoods where the Almighty refuses to deliver?

Does the divine presence disappear when somebody votes differently, joins another religion, questions church doctrine, or declines to type AMEN beneath a Facebook post?

The biblical texts don’t support such a simplistic geographical arrangement.

More importantly, God’s presence and God’s approval are two entirely different propositions.

A person can believe God sustains their existence without concluding that God endorses their behavior.

Otherwise, every act of cruelty, dishonesty, exploitation, and violence would have to be interpreted as enjoying divine approval simply because its perpetrator remained alive.

And that would be a rather embarrassing theological position.

Especially for a religion that spends considerable time discussing sin.

LUKE 1:37: A MIRACLE, NOT A BLANK CHECK

Our meme triumphantly announces:

“For with God nothing shall be impossible.”

Luke 1:37.

Lovely verse.

But context, that troublesome little bastard, has entered the room.

The passage comes from Gabriel’s announcement concerning the extraordinary pregnancies of Elizabeth and Mary.

It’s about God’s ability to fulfill a divine promise.

It is not a contractual guarantee that every believer will win every argument, escape every consequence, survive every catastrophe, or receive a complimentary parking space outside Walmart.

The meme then offers biblical examples.

Sarah gave birth despite her advanced age.

David defeated Goliath.

Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego survived the furnace.

Lazarus was raised from the dead.

All marvelous stories within their respective religious traditions.

But there’s a rather significant problem with using them as proof that divine companionship guarantees worldly protection.

Job.

Remember Job?

Righteous fellow. Terrible luck.

Lost his possessions, his children, and his health while the heavenly administration conducted what may be history’s least defensible performance review.

Then there are the persecuted prophets.

The martyrs.

The countless faithful people who suffered despite their devotion.

And, of course, there’s Jesus.

Who was crucified.

Rather conspicuously.

If divine companionship guaranteed immunity from suffering, the central event of Christianity would be a spectacularly awkward counterexample.

Perhaps the meme’s author should have read beyond the inspirational highlights.

SATAN WOULD LIKE A WORD. ACTUALLY, HE WOULDN’T.

Now we arrive at my favorite part.

“Disappoint Satan by putting a true Amen!”

Oh, sweet merciful absurdity.

Apparently, the eternal struggle between good and evil has been reduced to Facebook comment engagement.

Somewhere in the infernal headquarters, a junior demon is nervously approaching the throne.

“Your Darkness, terrible news.”

“What is it, Wormwood?”

“Another seventy-three people typed AMEN beneath a picture of a sunset.”

“NOOOOOOO!”

“I’m afraid so, sir. One of them used six exclamation points.”

“Then all is lost.”

Unfortunately for this theological masterpiece, the history of Satan is considerably more complicated than the meme suggests.

The Hebrew word satan originally meant an adversary or opponent.

In portions of the Hebrew Bible, the term describes an adversarial role rather than necessarily identifying the fully developed supernatural enemy familiar from later Christianity.

In Job, ha-satan—the accuser—appears among the heavenly beings.

The concept developed across centuries of Jewish and Christian thought.

And then, in 1966, Anton Szandor LaVey founded the Church of Satan.

Here’s where things become deliciously interesting.

The Church of Satan doesn’t believe in a literal supernatural Satan.

Its Satan is symbolic.

He represents individualism, skepticism, pride, liberty, and opposition to certain forms of religious authority.

LaVeyan Satanism is atheistic.

Its adherents do not believe a horned supernatural creature is monitoring Facebook for insufficiently enthusiastic Christians.

In fact, one of LaVey’s Nine Satanic Statements declares:

“Satan represents undefiled wisdom instead of hypocritical self-deceit!”

Now, the Church of Satan doesn’t possess exclusive historical authority over the biblical Satan, and Christian traditions understand the figure very differently.

But it’s worth appreciating the irony.

The people who explicitly identify with Satan as a religious symbol generally don’t believe in the supernatural being this meme is attempting to irritate.

And the people who do believe in that being apparently think he can be defeated through social-media participation.

What a magnificent species we are.

GOD KNOWS YOUR HEART. FACEBOOK NEEDS YOUR COMMENT.

Here’s another delightful contradiction.

Matthew 6 warns against performing religious devotion merely to be seen by others.

Jesus criticizes ostentatious public piety and emphasizes sincerity over spectacle.

Yet this meme effectively tells people to demonstrate their religious allegiance by making a visible declaration beneath somebody else’s content.

Not because they’ve examined the passage.

Not because they’ve contemplated its meaning.

Not because they’ve undertaken an act of kindness, mercy, or justice.

Because they typed four letters.

A-M-E-N.

Congratulations.

You’ve apparently disappointed Satan.

Meanwhile, somewhere in the world, a hungry child remains hungry, a vulnerable person remains unprotected, and someone suffering injustice continues waiting for help.

But at least the algorithm knows you’re spiritually committed.

AND NOW, THE QUESTION NOBODY WANTS TO ANSWER.

If we’re going to invoke God as the ultimate moral authority, perhaps we should examine what the scriptures actually demand.

Micah 6:8 speaks of justice, mercy, and humility.

Isaiah 1 condemns religious observance divorced from justice.

Amos 5 rejects worship that coexists with oppression and demands that justice flow like water.

Matthew 25 places extraordinary emphasis on the treatment of hungry people, strangers, prisoners, and those in need.

And 1 John 4:20 delivers a particularly uncomfortable observation:

Anyone claiming to love God while hating another person is a liar.

That’s rather more demanding than typing AMEN.

It also raises questions about how we evaluate religious and political leaders.

Consider Jeffrey Epstein’s documented sexual abuse and trafficking of girls, the criminal conviction of Ghislaine Maxwell, and the institutional failures surrounding those crimes.

Consider the importance of distinguishing established wrongdoing from allegations, social associations, and unsupported accusations.

Consider political leaders, including Donald Trump, whose conduct and exercise of authority have generated extensive litigation, judicial findings, public controversy, and competing claims about legality and morality.

The relevant questions are specific.

What actually happened?

What evidence establishes it?

Who was harmed?

Who bears responsibility?

What laws or moral obligations were violated?

And are we willing to apply those standards consistently, including when the person under scrutiny belongs to our preferred political movement?

Religious identity is not evidence of innocence. Political allegiance is not a substitute for moral judgment.

Nor does an expression of faith automatically invalidate someone else’s beliefs, experiences, or dignity.

A person can profess profound love for God while behaving cruelly toward other people.

A person can reject supernatural religion while living a life of extraordinary compassion.

And someone can spend every Sunday in church without ever learning the difference between righteousness and self-righteousness.

The Bible itself repeatedly warns about precisely that distinction.

Which brings us to the uncomfortable possibility that the greatest spiritual danger isn’t somebody refusing to type AMEN.

It might be somebody who types AMEN enthusiastically while refusing to examine their own conduct.

THE ALMIGHTY DOESN’T NEED A PUBLIC RELATIONS DEPARTMENT.

If God is omniscient, God already knows what you believe.

If God is omnipresent, God isn’t waiting for an algorithm to deliver you into the divine service area.

If God is just, declarations of religious loyalty cannot erase wrongdoing.

And if God is love, perhaps love deserves to be measured by something more substantial than the number of inspirational graphics we circulate.

Love without responsibility is an incomplete moral claim.

Faith without reflection is vulnerable to manipulation.

And professed righteousness without accountability is an invitation to hypocrisy.

None of this requires rejecting God.

It requires taking the moral implications of belief seriously.

So, by all means, believe.

Pray.

Study.

Question.

Love your neighbor.

Feed somebody who’s hungry.

Protect somebody who’s vulnerable.

Tell the truth when it’s inconvenient.

Acknowledge your mistakes.

Make amends when you’ve caused harm.

And resist the temptation to confuse your own certainty with divine endorsement.

But please, for the love of everything holy, stop pretending the Creator of the Universe requires a Facebook engagement campaign to defeat Satan.

God, if God exists as described, has considerably more important things to attend to.

And Satan?

Well, according to the Church of Satan, he doesn’t exist as a supernatural being in the first place.

Which means the poor bastard has somehow managed to lose a social-media competition he never entered.

AMEN.

Posted without divine authorization. No demons were harmed in the preparation of this commentary. One algorithm may have experienced mild spiritual discomfort.

What happens to a society when being able to see the bullshit is no longer enough to stop it?

What if the greatest existential danger isn’t that AI will develop humanity’s worst characteristics—but that we will give it our worst institutional incentives while assuming intelligence alone will somehow produce our best moral qualities?